Exploring High-Frequency Electromagnetic Theory with ANSYS HFSS

Categories:

I recently had the opportunity to present an interesting experimental research paper at DesignCon 2017, titled Replacing High-Speed Bottlenecks with PCB Superhighways. The motivation behind the research was to develop a new high-speed signaling system using rectangular waveguides, but the most exciting aspect for me personally was salvaging a (perhaps contentious) 70 year old first-principles electromagnetic model. While it took some time to really understand how to apply the mathematics to design, their application led to an exciting convergence of theory, simulation, and measurement.

One of the most critical aspects of the design was exciting the waveguide with a monopole probe antenna. Many different techniques have been developed to match the antenna impedance to the waveguide impedance at the desired frequency, as well as increase the bandwidth. Yet, all of them rely on assumptions and empirical measurement studies. Optimizing a design to nanometer precision empirically would be difficult at best and even if the answer was found it wouldn’t inherently reveal the physics. To solve this problem, we needed a first-principles model, a simulation tool that could quickly iterate designs accurately, and some measurements to validate the simulation methodology.

A rigorous first-principles model was developed by Robert Collin in 1960, but this solution has since been forgotten and replaced by simplified rules. Unfortunately, these simplified rules are unable to deliver an optimal design or offer any useful insight to the critical parameters. In fairness, Collin’s equations are difficult to implement in design and validating them with measurement would be tedious and expensive. Because of this, empirical measurements have been considered a faster and cheaper alternative. However, we wanted the best of both worlds… we wanted the best design, for the lowest cost, and we wanted the results quickly.

For this study, we used ANSYS HFSS to simulate our designs. Before exploring new designs, we first wanted to validate our simulation methodology by correlating results with available measurements. We were able to demonstrate a strong agreement between Collin’s theory, ANSYS HFSS simulation, and VNA measurement.

padt ansys hfss theory f03
Red simulated S-parameters strongly correlated with blue measurements.

To perform a series of parametric studies, we swept thousands of antenna design iterations across a wide frequency range of 50 GHz for structures ranging from 50-100 guide wavelengths long. High-performance computing gave us the ability to solve return loss and insertion loss S-parameters within just a few minutes for each design iteration by distributing across 48 cores.

padt ansys hfss theory f04
Sample Parametric Design Sweep

Finally, we used the lessons we learned from Collin’s equations and the parametric study to develop a new signaling system with probe antenna performance never before demonstrated. You can read the full DesignCon paper here:

The outcome also pertains to RF applications in addition to potentially addressing Signal Integrity concerns for future high-speed communication channels.

Rules-of-thumb are important to fast and practical design, but their application can many times be limited. Competitive innovation demands we explore beyond these limitations but the only way to match the speed and accuracy of design rules is to use simulations capable of offering fast design exploration with the same reliability as measurement. ANSYS HFSS gave us the ability to, not only optimize our design, but also teach us about the physics that explain our design and allow us to accurately predict the behavior of new innovative designs.

Get Your Ansys Products & Support from the Engineers who Contribute to this Blog.

Technical Expertise to Enable your Additive Manufacturing Success.

Share this post:

Upcoming Events

Apr 29
, 2025
New NVH Tools & Workflows in Ansys 2025 R1 - Webinar
Apr 29
, 2025
Design, Debug, and Test your Ansys Scade One Model - Webinar
May 01
, 2025
Applying Digital Engineering across Space Mission Analysis and Design - Webinar
May 07
, 2025
Meshing Updates in Ansys 2025 R1 - Webinar
May 07
, 2025
Transforming Robot Arm Design with Topology Optimization - Webinar
May 13
, 2025
Ansys Virtual Workshop - PCB Reliability with Sherlock
May 13
, 2025
Dynamic RF Interference: HFSS and STK for Antenna Array Control - Webinar
May 15
, 2025
Applying Digital Engineering across Space Mission Analysis and Design: Satellite - Webinar
May 21
, 2025
Optics Updates in Ansys 2025 R1 - Webinar
May 29
, 2025
Applying Digital Engineering across Space Mission Analysis and Design: Payload - Webinar
Jun 04
, 2025
Composites & Structural Optimization Updates in Ansys 2025 R1 - Webinar
Jun 09
- Jun 11
, 2025
TechConnect World 2025
Jun 18
, 2025
Fluent CPU - UI & UX Updates in Ansys 2025 R1 - Webinar
Jun 16
- Jun 20
, 2025
Turbo Expo
Jun 25
, 2025
E-Mobility and Clean Energy Summit
Jul 02
, 2025
Electric Machine & Consumer Electronics Updates in Ansys 2025 R1 - Webinar
Jul 11
, 2025
2025 Aerospace, Aviation, Defense and Manufacturing Conference
Jul 16
, 2025
HFSS Updates in Ansys 2025 R1 - Webinar
Aug 10
- Aug 13
, 2025
SmallSat 2025

Search the PADT Site

Contact Us

Most of our customers receive their support over the phone or via email. Customers who are close by can also set up a face-to-face appointment with one of our engineers.

For most locations, simply contact us: