In Ansys Maxwell, windings can be added in Eddy Current and Transient Solvers. There are two types of conductors when assigning the windings: Solid and Stranded. What is the difference?
The Solid type considers the conductor as a solid part and therefore, the eddy current and AC effects will be taken into consideration. While the Stranded type assumes the conductor consists of infinite strands of tiny conductors and therefore, there is no eddy current inside the conductor.
Now if there is no time-varying current or magnetic field in the model, will it be the same using Solid or Stranded? The answer is NO. Figure 1 shows a simple geometry of one-turn copper conductor. The cross-section is 1 mm by 1 mm and length of each edge is 100 mm. Assume the winding type is External and the circuit is shown below in Figure 2. The winding is connected to an external resistance (0.003 ohm) and the DC voltage source is 1 V.
The question will be: what is the current in the winding? Based on the physical geometry of the conductor, the conductor resistance can be calculated byR=ρ L/A, where L is the length of the conductor, A is the cross-sectional area and ρ is the resistivity of the copper material. The calculated conductor resistance is about 0.006872 ohm. The winding current will be different based on conductor type.
When the conductor is selected as Solid in ANSYS Maxwell, the winding resistance will be included while calculating the current. Therefore, the winding current will be:
Note: if the winding resistance is changing, the winding current will also change.
And the winding loss will be:
The winding loss calculated by Ansys Maxwell is 70.57 W which is identical to the result above.
When the conductor is selected as Stranded in Ansys Maxwell, the winding resistance will NOT be included while calculating the current. Therefore, the winding current will be:
Note: the winding current is a constant no matter the winding resistance changes or not.
And the winding loss will be:
The winding loss calculated by Ansys Maxwell is 763.55 W which is identical to the result above.
The Solid type is needed if the AC effect is of interest.
For Voltage winding type, the DC winding current and DC winding loss will be different for Solid and Stranded types. If the load resistance is much larger/smaller than the winding resistance, this difference can be neglected.
If the user is using the Voltage source and doing the EM-Thermal coupling simulation, it requires more attention as the temperature rise will increase the winding resistance and therefore, decrease the winding current (as the voltage is fixed). In this case, users can either choose Solid or add an additional scaling factor in the material property to compensate for the current difference.
If you would like more information related to this topic or have any questions, please reach out to us at email@example.com.
Getting zapped by static electricity at the personal level
is merely annoying; having your sensitive electronic equipment buzzed is
another, highly destructive story.
Much as you’d like to send these components out into the
world wearing their own little anti-static wristbands, that’s just not
practical (and actually, not good enough*). During build and use, advanced
electronics applications need true charge-dissipative protection that is
inherent to their design and easy to achieve. However, the typical steps of
painting or coating, covering with conductive tape, or wrapping with
carbon-filled/aluminum-coated films incur both time and cost.
Electrostatic dissipative (ESD) polymer materials instead provide this kind of protection on a built-in basis, offering a moderately conductive “exit path” that naturally dissipates the charge build-up that can occur during normal operations. It also prevents powders, dust or fine particles from sticking to the surface. Whether the task is protecting circuit boards during transport and testing, or ensuring that the final product works as designed throughout its lifetime, ESD materials present low electrical resistance while offering the required mechanical, and often thermal and/or chemically-resistant properties.
Combining ESD Behavior with 3D Printing
All the features that are appealing with 3D printing carry
over when printing with ESD-enabled thermoplastics. You can print trays custom-configured
to hold circuit-boards for in-process testing, print conformal fixtures that
speed up sorting, and produce end-use structures for projects where static
build-up is simply not allowed (think mission-critical aerospace applications).
Acrylonitrile butadiene styrene (ABS), that work-horse of
the plastics industry, has been available as 3D printing filament for decades.
Along the way, Stratasys
and other vendors started offering this filament in a version filled with
carbon particles that decrease the plastic’s inherent electrical resistance.
Stratasys ABS-ESD7 runs on the Fortus 380, 400, 450 and 900 industrial systems,
and soon will be available on the office-friendly F370 printer.
What kind of performance does ABS-ESD7 offer? When
evaluating materials for ESD performance, the most important property is
usually the surface resistance, measured in ohms. (This is not the same as surface
resistivity, plus there’s also volume resistivity – see Note at end). Conductive
materials – typically metals – have a surface resistance generally less than 103
ohms, insulators such as most plastics are rated at greater than 1012
ohms, and ESD materials fall in the mid-range, at 106 to 109
Compared to standard ABS filament, ABS-ESD7 offers more than five orders of magnitude lower resistance, converting it from an insulator to a material that provides an effective static-discharge path to the outside world. Due to the inherent layered structure of FDM parts, the differences in properties between flat (XY) and vertical (ZX) build orientations produces a range of resistance values, with a target of 107 ohms, reflected in the product name of ABS-ESD7. Stratasys offers an excellent, easy-to-read FAQ paper about ABS-ESD7.
When ABS isn’t strong enough or won’t hold up to temperature extremes, engineers can turn to Stratasys’ ESD-enhanced polyetherketoneketone (PEKK), termed Antero 840CN03. Developed in 2016 and slated for full release in October 2019, this new filament expands the company’s Antero line of high-temperature, chemically resistant formulations. The PEKK base material offers a high glass transition temperature (Tg 149C, compared to 108C for ABS-ESD7) while meeting stringent outgassing and cleanroom requirements. As with ABS-ESD7, the carbon-nanotube loading lowers electrical resistance values of Antero 840CN03 parts to the desirable “ESD safe” range of 106 to 109 ohm.
Setting up Parts for Printing with ESD-Enhanced Filament
Support structures in contact with part walls/surfaces can disturb the surface resistance behavior. To counter-act this condition for filament printing with any type of ESD material, users should perform a special calibration that makes the printer lay down slightly thinner-than-usual layers of support material. In Stratasys Insight software, this is currently accomplished by setting the Support Offset Thickness to -0.003; this decreases the support layers from 0.010 inches to 0.007 inches. In addition, supports should be removed (in Insight software) from holes that are smaller in diameter than 0.25 inches (6.35mm).
As more of these materials are developed, the software will be updated to automatically create supports with this process in mind.
ESD Applications for 3D Printing
Avionics boxes, fixtures for holding and transporting
circuit boards, storage containers for fuel, and production-line conveyor
systems are just a few examples of end-use applications of ESD-enabled
materials. Coupled with the geometric freedom offered by 3D printing, three
categories of manufacturing and operations are improved:
Protecting electronics from ESD damage (static
If you’re exploring how 3D printing with ESD-enhanced
materials can help with your industrial challenge, contact our PADT
Manufacturing group: get your questions answered, have some sample parts
printed, and discover what filament is right for you.
is a globally recognized provider of Numerical Simulation, Product Development
and 3D Printing products and services. For more information on Insight, GrabCAD
and Stratasys products, contact us at firstname.lastname@example.org.
*Anti-static is a qualitative term and refers to something that prevents build-up of static, rather than dissipating what does occur
Surface Resistivity and Volume Resistivity
Surface resistance in ohms is a
measurement to evaluate static-dissipative packaging materials.
for measuring surface resistance of ESD materials is EOS/ESD S11.11, released
in 1993 by the ESD
Association as an improvement over ASTM D-257 (the classic standard
for evaluating insulators). Driving this need was the non-homogeneous structure
of ESD materials (conductive material added to plastic), which had a different
effect on testing parameters such as voltage or humidity, than found with evaluating conductors.
Volume resistivity is yet a third
possible measured electrical property, though again better suited for true conductors
rather than ESD material. It depends on the area of the ohmeter’s electrodes
and the thickness of the material sample. Units are ohm-cm or ohm-m.